Minority moments
I'm 35 years old. White. Heterosexual. Married. Middle class. College educated. Normal. I don't find myself out on the extreme of anything, really. I'm not outcast or finding myself in the margins. I don't get too excited to admit it, but I'm a fairly average, middle of the pack, regular kind of guy.
It's usually people like me that have segregated, outcast and marginalized others so it was weird for me to have my "own" people turn on me. I experienced a minority moment. What it felt like to be the only "different" one in a crowd. To be looked at, looked down at. To want to cave in just to fit in.
Keeping details to a minimum...It was decided to place the winter (which means temporary) tent homeless shelter just 2 blocks from where I live. The chosen location is in the center of East Village, our rapidly redeveloping downtown neighborhood. While I agree that the chosen location is not great, the homeless tent will be far less attractive than the lynch mob mentality of the 75 people that showed up at a meeting to voice their complaints. It was a meeting full of anger. Where most struggled to even identify a homeless person as human. And while most there shared this feeling, I stood in the back very dissapointed with my neighbors with the phrase, "shame on us" running through my mind.
Could it be that I am the only one that feels differently about this (I found out later that at least one other felt similar), well I wasn't about to speak out publicly for fear of my life. What I have learned, or maybe been reminded of, is that most of us really want to help and make a difference in our world as long as it doesn't affect us. But as soon as the issue is in my backyard...
But then these fires started burning up all of San Diego, a problem in our cities backyard. A problem each of us is having to deal with (Even now as I sit in a coffee shop typing, many miles from the fire, ashes are floating across the front of my computer screen). And many are chipping in to make a difference, to help, volunteer, donate, pray. I am anything but dissapointed with my neighbors this week. Why will we help in the wake of a tragic fire, but not step in and help the homeless? Why such different attitudes from the same people? I'm sure you have opinions, so I won't share mine.
What I keep thinking about is why didn't I speak up at the meeting. Why did I wait? Although one friend said it would have been like telling an alcoholic to sober up when he is wasted (point taken), I still could have spoken. I often sense this need to express my different opinion, my prophetic voice (I will answer what this is on Wednesday) if you will.
But it can be hard. Hard to speak up. Hard to speak my mind. Hard to intentionally stick myself out there. So often we keep quiet.
I finally spoke up. I let my "prophetic voice" out. Now I wait for reaction, response, and the difference it may make (hopefully good).
It's hard to focus and think much these days beyond what is going on with our city. The fires, the evacuations, the hundreds of destroyed homes. Many people continue to ask what we might do. I trust you will do what you can, when you can. I also want to encourage you to pray, believing it will help bring an end to the destruction and comfort to the hurting.
embracing life
Another perspective on life, worldviews, and God - and how they all fit together in everyday experience. Simple stuff.
5 Comments
4:39 PM
Well, don't be too hard on yourself. If we all spoke up every time we knew in our hearts we "should"....we would all be Ghandi. Your original intent and voiced opinion online is much appreciated.
11:09 PM
Keeping quiet sucks, especially when you're gut tells you that what you have to say is really important, even if it's almost certain it won't be well-received. I'm quiet about stuff too.
Sometimes doesn't it feel like being quiet about something that matters a lot to you is causing you to miss out on your purpose? Like, there's something you want to do - but you can't do it until you stop being quiet about it. Until you speak that truth you're holding inside, you'll never be able to discover what real purpose is behind it all.
For you, you had a conviction about the homeless shelter and people's attitudes toward other people - but initially you didn't speak up because of fear. Now that you're speaking that conviction, don't you sense some purpose behind it, behind the conversations you are having, behind the homeless shelter being in East Village to begin with?
I haven't figured out the purpose part yet because I'm still quiet about my conviction.
8:49 AM
dude, i'm quiet all the time. especially in group settings... so often i hear people say "Billy's always quiet" like its who I am, like its my identity. I am quiet.
I dont want to always be quiet... I just am I dont know why. If you figure that one out, let me know. I feel like I have stuff to say, I feel like I can contribute to the conversation, whatever it may be about. I dont know how to say it in a way that might be well received or at least understood. I feel like i understand so well, both 'sides' so clearly I see what everyone is saying... but never so clearly can i communicate my own thoughts in a way that might be well received or 'accepted' perhaps unifying. so i sit. i think. i wonder. untill the time to speak has passed and i sit back some more. Ultimately i convince myself that the right outcome happened reguardless of if i spoke or not, and it is better for me to listen than to speak. after all, I am quiet.
9:00 AM
On the homeless dudes for the winter... where is a better place for them to be? no matter the location chosen, surrounding un-homeless people would be all pumped about that as the wrong spot. It seems many of the homeless,and many of the facilities for the homeless are in the downtown area, it makes sense for a winter shelter to be relatively nearby. ought we do away with one all togeather? Is that the argument? You know my stance. Of corse not. Why not? likely they will still get high or drunk, likely will still remain homeless either way. might some die without out the tent? that would lower the homeless population right?
why do we help? why should we help?
Life? Compassion? Love? Hope? All things you must feel. How do you convince someone to feel?
So I sit. remain quiet. feel on my own, hoping that might be enough.
8:59 AM
i always know you got plenty going on in that red head of yours billy. and on those occasions when you do talk, it's always a breath of fresh air. i like hearing what you have to say. maybe blog comments are a good way to start :)
Post a Comment